IG vs TD Ameritrade | Our Analysis & Comparison in 2024

Published :
Written by

IG

Founded in 1974 as IG Index by Bristish Financier Stuart Wheeler, IG is a well known forex and CFD broker.It  offers offer over 100 forex currency pairs, cfxfds, commodities, stocks, index, gold, silver, oil, bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies for your personal investment and trading options.

IG Markets Overview
  • Founded In: 1974
  • Minimum Deposit: $250
  • Maximum Leverage: 200:1
  • Regulations: ASIC, FCA, FSA, NFA , AMF, FMA, MAS, DFSA
  • Trading platform: MT4, WebTrader, MobileTrader (MobileApp), ProRealTime
  • Account Types: Standard account, DMA Account
  • Payment Options: Bank Wire (BankTransfer/SWIFT), VISA, MasterCard, PayPal
  • US Traders:  Accepted 

TD Ameritrade

Founded in 1971 as Ameritrade, TD Ameritrade is a well-known American online brokerage firm that offers a wide range of financial services including stocks, Forex,  options, ETFs Mutual Funds, fixed income and other investment products  TD Ameritrade went through a couple of acquisitions and mergers. In 2006, it acquired the US operations of TD Waterhouse, followed by the acquisition of Scottrade in 2017. Finally, in 2020, Charles Schwab Corporation acquired TD Ameritrade. TD Ameritrade provides access to both US and non-US traders to trade on this platform. 

TD Ameritrade At a Glance

TD Ameritrade At a Glance
  • Founded In: 1978
  • Minimum Deposit: $0
  • Maximum Leverage: 1:50
  • Regulations: SEC , FINRA , SIPC
  • Trading platform: Web Platforms, thinkorswim desktop, thinkorswim® web, Mobile Trading
  • Account Types: Standard, Retirement, Education and Specialty accounts.
  • Payment Options: Bank Wire (BankTransfer/SWIFT), ACH (Automated Clearing House), Check, Physical Stock Certificates, Transfer from Existing Broker
  • US Clients : Accepted

IG vs TD Ameritrade: Pros and Cons

IG Pros & Cons

Pros
  • Regulated by multiple top tire regulators like  NFA,  FCA, ASIC, FSA, AMF, FMA, MAS, DFSA 
  • Allows scalping, EA/ Robot Trading, News Trading
  • Offers web trading, mobile trading and ECN Trading 
  • IG's acquisition of tastytrade for $1 billion brought options trading and listed-derivatives (such as futures) trading to clients in the United States
  • 16,000 trading instruments, investments in IPOs and exchange-traded funds;
  • Quality choice of trading platforms, including MT4, WebTrader, MobileTrader (MobileApp), ProRealTime
  • Relatively good spreads, from 0.6-1 pips depending on the type of instrument;
  •  Offers passive investment programme ( MAM, PAMM accounts)
Cons
  • Relatively high Minimum deposit ( Min Deposit $250) 
  • Conservative leverage in some areas  ( The max leverage is 1:200)
  • IG charges $/£12/€14 per month after 24 months of inactivity 
  • Limited product range on MT4
  • High Stock CFD fees 

TD Ameritrade Pros & Cons

Pros
  • ETF, non-penny stock, and options trades are commission-free
  • Expansive trading tools and resources for all types of investors
  • Low trading fees (free stock and ETF trading)
  • Regulated by FINRA, SIBC 
  • Part of Charles Schwab Corporation since October 2020, with a combined 28 million clients and $6 trillion in assets.
  • The company does not charge fees for trading in American and Canadian stocks, options, and ETFs.
  • There is a large selection of investments from which to choose
Cons
  • Broker-assisted trades are somewhat costly
  • No direct crypto Trading 
  • Forex trading via thinkorswim, a trading platform where you can trade forex
  • No MT4, MT5, cTraders  trading platforms are offered 
  • Fractional shares are not offered
  • Accounts mostly limited to US residents
  • As a U.S.-only forex broker, TD Ameritrade does not offer copy trading or MetaTrader (MT4).

IG vs TD Ameritrade: Side-by-Side Comparison

IG.com
TD Ameritrade
Product
Founded In
Founded In
1974
1978
Founded By
Founded By
Stuart Wheeler
John Joseph Ricketts
Headquarters
Headquarters
London, UK
Omaha, United State
Regulations
Regulations
ASIC , FSCA ,DFSA , FCA,NFA, FSA, AMF, MAS, FMA, DFSA
SEC , CFTC
Min Deposit
Min Deposit
$50
None
Max Leverage
Max Leverage
50:1
50:1
Tradable Assets
Tradable Assets
Indices, Forex ,Shares, Commodities ,Cryptocurrencies, Bond
Stocks,Options,ETFs,Mutual Funds,Futures,Forex,Margin Trading,Bonds & Fixed Income.
Fees
Fees
Spread from EURUSD 0.6 Gold 0.3 (Standard Account)
Spread from
Platforms and Tools
Platforms and Tools
MT4, WebTrader, MobileTrader (MobileApp), ProRealTime
Web ,Mobile , thinkorswim Trading Platforms
US Traders
US Traders
Allowed
Allowed

IG Vs TD Ameritrade: Our Scores and Ratings

We rated both brokers, IG and TD Ameritrade, on a scale of 1 to 10, with 0.1 increments. To achieve a comprehensive rating, we broadly grouped all services offered by brokers into 6 macro categories and assigned percentage weights to them. Each macro category is subdivided into several data points which contributes to the total score of 1.0-10.0 assigned to each macro category. Since all categories are not equally important, our weight percentage plays a significant role in assessing the broker accurately. For example, Regulation and Security contributes a total weight of 40% to the whole ratings because this is the most important rating category. To learn more, read our methodology.

IG:

9
Total Score
Regulation and Security (40%)10
Fees and Commissions (20%)9
Trading (15%)8
Trading tools (10%)8
Customer Support (10%)8
Trading Education (5%)8

TD Ameritrade

8.8
TD Ameritrade Score
Regulation and Security (40%)9
Fees and Commissions (20%)9
Trading (15%)9
Trading tools (10%)8
Customer Support (10%)8
Trading Education (5%)7

Final Verdict :

Written by

Jason Paine is a forex trader, researcher, and tech enthusiast. He is passionate about financial markets and cutting-edge technology. With a dynamic 16-year trading career, he's on a mission to guide fellow traders. Having navigated diverse forex brokers, Jason shares his insights at Brokersway to bridge the gap between traders and the right brokerage.

DisclosureAt Brokersway we're committed to delivering unbiased information. our opinions are our own and are not influenced by the payment we receive from our advertising partners. While we adhere to strict editorial integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners. Here's an explanation of how we make money.

Leave a Comment